Victory for Porsche 911 Owner: Mechanic’s 11-Year Car Hostage Crisis Ends in Court
The Unbelievable Story of a Porsche Owner’s Nightmare with a Dodgy Mechanic
When Dr. Penelope Horlick purchased her 1997 Porsche 911 Targa in 2008, she never imagined that a simple pothole incident would lead to a 11-year-long ordeal with a shady mechanic. The incident caused undercarriage damage, including an oil leak, and Jhally, the mechanic, quoted her £9,000 (approximately $11,800 today) for the repairs.
A Promise Unkept
Despite receiving the quote, Jhally never completed the repairs. He would frequently delay and make empty promises, claiming the work was almost done. Dr. Horlick’s patience wore thin, but she continued to give Jhally concessions when he faced health issues and even spent time in jail for assault-related charges.
The Lawsuit
In 2022, Dr. Horlick decided to take legal action, filing a suit against Jhally for breach of contract, the purchase of a replacement vehicle (she bought an Audi in 2014), and distress due to the loss of her prized possession. Jhally, in a bizarre move, countersued for reimbursement of parts and repairs, and claimed Dr. Horlick’s suit was past the statute of limitations.
The Verdict
After a three-day trial, Judge John Halford ruled in Dr. Horlick’s favor, ordering Jhally to pay £114,000 (approximately $151,000) in compensation. The judge criticized Jhally for not completing the work with reasonable care and skill, stating, "Nobody buys a Porsche to have a car – they buy a Porsche to have a Porsche."
Lessons Learned
This case serves as a cautionary tale for car owners. It’s essential to do your research, read reviews, and thoroughly vet mechanics before entrusting them with your vehicle. Remember, a promise is only as good as the person making it. Don’t let a simple pothole incident turn into a decade-long nightmare like Dr. Horlick’s.
Image: [Image: 1997 Porsche 911 Targa]
Key Takeaways:
- Always research and vet mechanics before entrusting them with your vehicle
- Be cautious of mechanics who make empty promises and delay repairs
- Keep detailed records of your interactions with the mechanic, including quotes and correspondence
- Consider seeking legal advice if you’re experiencing difficulties with a mechanic
Sources:
