Rings of Power’s Trust Issue: Why Letting Go of Control Might Be the Key to Success
Trust is a crucial concept in Middle-earth, and it’s something the creators of The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power are keen to drive home in the show’s latest episode. It’s a theme that permeates the narrative, highlighting the importance of trust in relationships and between characters. In episode 4, we see this theme play out in several storylines, each one exploring the consequences of trust – or the lack thereof.
The Elrond and Galadriel plot is easily the strongest of the episode, with the two characters embodying the trust issues at the heart of the show. Their disagreement over the Ring of Power is authentic and feels deeply rooted in their characters. It’s a debate with two valid sides, and their disagreement adds depth to the narrative. The tension between them is palpable, making their eventual resolution all the more satisfying.
In contrast, the Pelargir subplot feels somewhat flat, with Isildur and Arondir’s trust in Estrid feeling more like a plot device than a genuine emotional connection. It’s a shame, because the potential for tension and drama is there, but it’s not fully explored. The show’s writers seem to be relying too heavily on convenient plot developments rather than character-driven drama.
The inclusion of the entwives is another missed opportunity. Rather than using them as a way to explore the lore and world-building of Middle-earth, they feel like a contrived addition to the narrative. It’s a cheap way to get a rise out of fans of the books, rather than trusting the audience to invest in the story.
On the other hand, the barrow-wight fight is a standout moment in the episode, using the setting and atmosphere to create a sense of tension and danger. It’s a great example of how the show can use the world of Middle-earth to tell compelling stories, rather than relying on fan service.
Overall, episode 4 of The Rings of Power is a mixed bag. While it has some great moments, it’s also guilty of relying on cheap tricks and plot devices. Here’s hoping the show can iron out its trust issues before the Siege of Eregion, because that’s exactly what we need to make this story come alive.
